In 1987 the World Commission on Environment and Development, ( WCED 1987 ) stated that “ Humanity has the ability to do development sustainable to guarantee that it meets the demands of the present without compromising the ability of future coevalss to run into their ain demands ” . There Out of the many definitions of sustainability this profound statement has become the most widely accepted. It is what these demands are, how we impact upon them and how out impact can be measured or assessed that raises the most argument. ( Parkin et al. 2003 ) Sustainability is frequently symbolised utilizing three over lapping circles ( fig 1 ) , stand foring the three facets of sustainability ( society, economic system and environment ) . However this simple diagram over simplifies the complex interactions which occur between the facets and the big figure of indexs which are used to mensurate our impact. Unless these complex interactions are clearly understood by all the stakeholders it would be impossible to to the full measure the sustainability of any development ( Foxon et al. 2002 ) . A figure of determination support tools have been created to help determination shapers in accomplishing sustainable urban developments. There has been immense attempt and resources put into making DSTs, yet despite this most are seldom used due to either the complexness of their operation or the complexness of their end product ( Isaacs et al. 2007 ) . It is hence believed that there is a demand for new determination support tools that can cover with the complexness of urban design and which go beyond the proficient orientation of old tools ( Sahota & A ; Jeffery 2005 ) to enable a robust appraisal of sustainability within the decision-making procedures.
Visual image has been used to help determination devising in a figure of Fieldss including increasing the safety and effectivity of oil boring in the oil and gas industry ( Evans et al. 2002 ) , visualizing medical informations ( Fuchs et al. 1989 ) and battlefield simulations ( Hix et al. 1999 ) . Geographic Information systems are presently the most extensively used visual image platform for determination devising. “ GIS is now a standard point in contrivers ‘ tool kits ” ( Drummond & A ; Gallic 2008 ) and there are many illustrations its usage in urban planning and determination devising over the last 20 old ages ( Harris & A ; Elmes 1993 ; Stevens et Al. 2007 ; States 2000 ; Shiffer 1998 ; Lodha & A ; Verma 2000 ) . Traditionally GIS provides the user with a synergistic information researching interface which allows them to cover a figure of different maps onto a 2D surface and allows the user to carry on complex geospatial analysis ( Salter et al. 2009 ) . However it has been shown ( Lowe 2004 ; Lowe 2003 ) that many non-expert stakeholders have great trouble in decoding and understanding scientific shows and maps. Due to its complexness and high acquisition curve GIS requires the user “ to believe like a geographic information scientist ” ( Clarke 2001 ) and is still considered to be a hard to utilize, adept tool ( Traynor & A ; Williams 1995 ) . Its usage in determination devising has made it hard for non expert stakeholders, particularly the general populace, to take part to the full in be aftering determinations ( Salter et al. 2009 ; Al-Kodmany 2002 ) .
Most GIS systems are purely 2D, covering with geospatial informations being draped over a map or other geographical representation. While experts can imagine the ocular impact of a proposed development from this program view it is really hard for person non trained in the usage of GIS to make this. This can take to non-expert stakeholder non to the full understanding the effects of the determinations being made and go forth them with an unintended positive or negative position of the planned development ( Danahy et al. 1999 ) . 3D representations nevertheless allow users to rapidly recognize the spacial context of the determination and besides to orientate their position of the proposed development ( Danahy et al. 1999 ) . Peoples develop the ability to voyage and visually process 3D representations of urban environments on a bomber witting degree throughout their lives as they walk through existent universe metropoliss ( Charters et al. 2002 ) . This sub witting ability means that the user will non hold to work to visualize the development but can concentrate on the determination, and the effects of the determination, being made.
S-City VT ( sustainable metropolis visual image tool ) is a paradigm determination support application that is designed to let a wider scope of stakeholders input into the sustainability planning procedure by leting the stakeholders to compare different scenarios utilizing a usage designed simulation and visual image engine.
Figure 1: Visual image techniques used in S-City VT
The visual image engine utilises a split screen rendering attack which allows the user, utilizing any of the techniques, to compare two scenarios side by side throughout the life rhythm of the development. A figure of visual image techniques have been used to expose the consequences of the implicit in simulation engine which allows the user to non merely compare the external visual aspect of the different scenarios but besides the comparative sustainability of each scenario.
As already discussed traditional GIS does non supply a realistic physical representation of the metropolis or development being studied. CAD system do enable the creative activity of 3D theoretical accounts which provide the user with a realistic representation of the edifices and the developments ( Al-Kodmany 2002 ) , nevertheless CAD systems provide no ability to cover extra informations and supply small context out with the edifice or country being studied.
The visual image engine combines GIS and 3D urban theoretical accounts and embeds the 3D theoretical accounts in the environing landscape to contextualise the urban country that is undergoing sustainability appraisal. The ability to visualize portion of the metropolis that is undergoing the development or regeneration within the wider metropolis context is likely to better battle with the communicating tool and convey a greater degree of engagement from all participants in the planning procedure ( Levy 1995 )
Fig 4: 3D representation of proposed development within the city-wide context.
The usage engine allows the user to hold synergistic control enabling the user to see the proposed development from any imaginable point of view. This allows the user to go to the full immersed in the proposed development, to a much greater grade than 2D programs, GIS, or rendered 3D stills. As has already been shown ( Isaacs et al. 2010a ) S City VT provides the user with a feasible representation of the existent development.
Design to Virtual Reality
Fig 5: Overview of the index blending technique
The blending technique, as shown in figure 5, merely takes the all the sustainability steps for each index, calculated by the bomber system and ANP theoretical accounts, unite them into a individual value. This valued is so mapped to a individual coloring material graduated table. The coloring material graduated table used can be selected from a figure of color graduated tables known for their discriminating abilities ( Levkowitz & A ; Herman 1992 ) these include the het object, magenta, local optimised, and spectral. Using the hot-cold graduated table demonstrated in figure 5 a edifice or floor with high comparative sustainability would look blue while a edifice with low sustainability would look ruddy. This method gives a individual index of sustainability and provides the easiest manner of comparing the comparative sustainability of different options or scenarios.
Fig 6: Overview of the index weaving technique
Whilst the blending technique, combines the index values, the weaving technique ( figure 6 ) efforts to continue some of the implicit in information so that the user can still place which indexs or bunch are doing the greatest consequence ( negative or positive ) on the sustainability of the edifice. The coloring material weaving technique ( Hagh-Shenas et al. 2007 ) uses a different coloring material graduated table for each index ( figure 6 ) to try to continue this information. The colors from each graduated table are so indiscriminately weaved into a hodgepodge like texture which is applied to each floor of the edifice. The size of the squares or spots in the weave can besides be changed depending on the user ‘s penchants. A little spot size will give an overall representation of the sustainability, with darker sunglassess stand foring low sustainability and lighter sunglassess stand foring higher sustainability. A larger spot size will let user to place rapidly which colours stand out the most, and hence which indexs are holding the greatest impact.
Traditional Graphical Techniques
Radar graphs, figure 7, let the stakeholder to compare the sustainability of different edifices based on the index values. The form, size, coloring material and point values will be different for each edifice leting a elaborate comparing.
Fig7: Comparision of scenarios utilizing traditional radio detection and ranging graphs and coloring material weaving.
Parallel coordinates allow the user to compare all index values for all the edifices in a scenario ( fihure 8 ) . Buildings can be selected and their hint in the graph is highlighted. The colors in the graph correspond to those in the blending technique.
Fig 8: Parallel co-ordinate graph for sample development.
Simple temporal graphs secret plan the all the index values over the life clip of the development. These allow the user to place the interconnectivity of the indexs and to place where and why sudden alterations occur ( figure 9 ) .
Fig 9: Index graph demoing alterations in 6 indexs over clip.
Real Time Simulation
The index patterning involves developing bomber theoretical accounts that define how each of the indexs vary over infinite and clip. The S-City VT application is built utilizing a modular model supplying flexibleness and leting index theoretical accounts to be changed. For the paradigm application six sustainability index theoretical accounts ( credence, lodging proviso, energy efficiency, noise pollution, employment and economic benefit ) have been developed four of which are described below:
The energy efficiency theoretical account is based on the Nation Calculation Method ( NCM ) which is the industry criterion leting energy efficiency of edifices to be determined ( BRE 2009 ) . The NCM method takes into history a broad scope of factors, including figure of room accesss, Windowss glazing type, exterior building, figure of floors etc, to bring forth a metric depicting the energy efficiency the edifice. A NCM study was developed utilizing the NCM tool, stand foring the typical edifices in the development for a figure of different options including external visual aspect and different mixes of edifice usage.
Fig2: Graph demoing temporal alterations in sustainability index due monthly energy fluctuations.
This information is input to the energy efficiency theoretical account and attenuated with the temporal energy ingestion informations ( BIS 2009 ) which reflects how the energy usage of the edifices change depending on the clip of twelvemonth. ( fig 2 ) shows how the sustainability index alterations as a map of clip for a 2 different constructing types with different utilizations ( glass, commercial and brick, residential ) .
The noise theoretical account calculates the degrees of traffic noise geting at each edifice and can besides cipher the proportion of people that will happen certain degrees of noise a nuisance. Datas about the jutting traffic flows for the waterfront development were sourced from Dundee metropolis councils Dundee Waterfront Traffic & A ; Signing Report ( White Young Green 2007 ) . For each route in the proposed development a noise degree is calculated utilizing its projected hourly traffic flow. Using a map provided in CRT ( 1988 ) , ( equation 1 ) this traffic flow can be transformed into a noise degree which corresponds to how loud, in dBs ( dubnium ( A ) ) , the traffic noise is if the hearer were standing about 10 meters off from the route side.
A noise degree associated at each edifice based on the traffic volume is calculated based on the shortest distance ( vitamin D ) between the noise beginning ( route ) and the edifice utilizing Euclidean geometry. The sound degree emanating from each route is obtained by rectifying the basic noise degree utilizing equation 2. The equation besides includes the tallness ( H ) of the hearer which is changeless in these computations. ( CRTN 1988 )
To find the entire noise degree received by the edifice the corrected noise from each route must be summed over n roads in the development ( equation 3 )
Each edifice will now hold a noise degree value stand foring the entire degree of noise associated with that edifices location in relation to the roads and their projected traffic flows. Our sustainability step is achieved by normalizing the noise degree ( 0-100 graduated table as before ) and using a non additive map ( equation 4 ( Highways Agency 1994 ) ) , this calculates the per centum of people that will be bothered by a specific degree of noise.
The economic theoretical account utilises a discounted hard currency flow computation to find the worth of a edifices current hard currency flow for a specific point in clip. The computation uses a price reduction rate which allows the hard currency flows to be discounted back to their present worth.
Where CF = hard currency flow for that twelvemonth. R = price reduction rate for that twelvemonth. t = the twelvemonth.
In the equation the capital cost for the building of the first edifice is represented by CF0. Capital costs of subsequent edifices will be discounted to this point clip. e.g. the capital cost of a edifice built two old ages after the initial edifice would be discounted utilizing.
Each edifice in the simulation has a site readying and building stage, during this clip the hard currency flow in for that period is taken every bit 0 as the edifice would non yet be sold or rented. The simulation is able to reflect the differences between hard currency flows for rented and sold edifices. Buildings which are sold will take a big income at the point of sale. As the edifice has been sold farther hard currency flows for this edifice will be 0. The price reduction factor will besides use to the sale income so for two edifices of tantamount value, a edifice sold in twelvemonth one will hold a higher present value than constructing sold in twelvemonth 10. As the edifice has been sold the upkeep and care of the edifice will be borne by the purchaser and so it non modelled here. Buildings which are rented will take a smaller income every twelvemonth. Rented edifices may hold a rent free period, to promote renters, and will hold a laic period between rentals, during these times the hard currency flow for that period will be 0. A price reduction factor is applied to the annual income to find its present value, once more based on the building twelvemonth of the first building..
Fig 3: PV for a individual edifice, built in twelvemonth 0, demoing differences between leased and sold income with different price reduction rates.
The initial cost of the edifices are calculated utilizing the edifice type ( e.g. residential, commercial, retail, societal ) and the cost per square meter for that type of edifice. The income from sale or rent is similarly calculated utilizing the jutting income for that type of edifice. These values were sourced from the SET economic study on the waterfront development ( Buchanan 2006 ) . The maximal and minimal valleies are so mapped onto 0 100 and linearly interpolated.
Acceptance corresponds to the credence of possible edifice utilizations within the development. The masterplan for Dundee has been developed and it was possible through treatment with Dundee council to find the possible edifice utilizations which are under reappraisal and included commercial office infinite, retail units, cafe/bar/restaurant and residential infinite. The edifice usage study used a superior system where the participant was asked to rank possible edifice utilizations in order of penchant. If the participant had no penchant between the edifice uses at each rank the proportions chosen at each rank would be equal. To find if this is the instance Friedman trial was performed utilizing SPSS on the average rank of each edifice usage, with the void hypothesis being that the average ranks will be equal.
Test Statistics a
a. Friedman Test
The consequences of the Friedman trial show that there is a important difference ( p & lt ; 0.001 ) between how the users ranked the different edifice utilizations. Combined with post-hoc analysis of the consequences it is possible to pattern the acceptableness edifice uses in the undermentioned order ; Leisure ( highest ranked ) , Retail & A ; Residential ( equal ranked ) and Commercial ( Lowest Ranked ) . To make a sustainability index for the acceptableness of each edifice these rankings are mapped onto a 0-100 graduated table, with Leisure at 100 ( highest sustainability ) , Retail & A ; Residential at 50 and Commercial ( lowest sustainability ) at 0.
MULTICRITERIA OPINION ANALYSIS
One of the jobs with traditional sustainability appraisal is affecting the positions and experiences of a broad scope of stakeholders ( ( Isaacs et al. 2010b ) , . Many of the traditional methods of aggregating index values, such as Multi Attribute Utility Theory ( MAUT ) , lack transparence go forthing the users in a place where they do non to the full understand how the resulting weightings have been derived ( Dodgson et al. 2009 ; Paracchini et Al. 2008 ) . The Analytic Network Process ( ANP ) method uses synergistic web constructions which give a more holistic representation of the overall job ( Saaty 2006 ) . Components of the job are connected, as appropriate, in braces with directed lines imitating the influence of one constituent over another. The constituents in a web may besides be regarded as elements that interact and influence each other in respect to a specific property. ( Saaty 2006 ) .
To execute a ANP analysis the determination shaper must place the web through analysis of the job to be solved. The determination shaper must place the bunchs, elements and the relationships and interactions between them ( Bottero et al. 2007 ) . Once the determination shaper has constructed the web to be analysed they must now make a supermatrix depicting the interactions defined in the theoretical account ( Gencer and Gurpinar 2007 ) . The supermatrix is created utilizing the cardinal graduated table and pair-wise method every interaction is described in footings of every component it interacts with ( Saaty 1999 ) . Once this has been completed the normalised eigenvector calculated from the matrix will give the determination shaper the normalised prioritised list of elements.
ANP allows cross-cluster interactions every bit good as inter-relationships between elements.. It is structured of course and allows for a more realistic representation of the job, but its chief strength lies in supplying the user with the ability to include their ain personal cognition and sentiments about an interaction through the usage of pair-wise comparings ( Saaty 2006, ; Bottero et Al. 2007 ) .
The prioritised list of elements which are derived from the ANP analysis are used in the 3D visual image to supply the user with a individual of sustainability index if required.
Al-Kodmany, K. ( 2002 ) Visual image tools and methods in community planning: from freehand studies to practical world. Journal of be aftering Literature, 17 ( 2 ) , p. 189. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //jpl.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/17/2/189.
BIS ( 2009 ) Energy Consumption in the UK. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //bis.ecgroup.net/Publications/EnergyClimateChangeDECC/EnergyStatistics.aspx.
BRE ( 2009 ) National Calculation Method, Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ncm.bre.co.uk/ .
Buchanan, C. ( 2006 ) Dundee Central Waterfront: Market Appraisal and Economic Impact Assessment. , 1.
CRTN ( 1988 ) Calculation of Road Traffic Noise Department Of Transport, London: HMSO.
Charters, S.M. , Knight, C. , Thomas, N. & A ; Munro, M. ( 2002 ) Visual image for informed determination devising ; from codification to constituents. In ACM New York, NY, USA, pp. 765-772.
Clarke, K.C. ( 2001 ) Geting started with geographic information systems, Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ.
Danahy, J. , Spiller, R. & A ; Verlag, W. ( 1999 ) Visualization Data Needs in Urban Environmental Planning and Design. Landscape Research. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary? doi=10.1.1.3.9259.
Dodgson, J. , Spackman, M. , Pearman, A. & A ; Phillips, L. ( 2009 ) Multi-criteria analysis: a manual, London: Department for Communities and Local Government.
Drummond, W. & A ; French, S. ( 2008 ) The Future of GIS in Planning: Converging Technologies and Diverging Interests. Journal of the American Planning Association, 74 ( 2 ) , pp. 161-174. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.informaworld.com/openurl? genre=article & A ; doi=10.1080/01944360801982146 & A ; magic=crossref||D404A21C5BB053405B1A640AFFD44AE3.
Evans, F. , Volz, W. , Dorn, G. , Frohlich, B. & A ; Roberts, D.M. ( 2002 ) Future trends in oil and gas visual image. In VIS ’02: Proceedings of the conference on Visualization ’02. Washington, DC, USA: IEEE Computer Society, pp. 567-570.
Foxon, T. , McIlkenny, G. , Gilmour, D. , Oltean-Dumbrava, C. , Souter, N. , Ashley, R. , Butler, D. , Pearson, P. , Jowitt, P. & A ; Moir, J. ( 2002 ) Sustainability standards for determination support in the UK H2O industry. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 45 ( 2 ) , p. 285-301. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ingentaconnect.com/content/routledg/cjep/2002/00000045/00000002/art00007.
Fuchs, H. , Levoy, M. & A ; Pizer, S.M. ( 1989 ) Interactive visual image of 3D medical informations. Computer, 22 ( 8 ) , pp. 46-51.
Hagh-Shenas, H. , Kim, S. , Interrante, V. & A ; Healey, C. ( 2007 ) Weaving versus blending: a quantitative appraisal of the information transporting capacities of two alternate methods for conveying multivariate informations with colour. IEEE minutess on visual image and computing machine artworks, 13 ( 6 ) , pp. 1270-7. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17968074.
Harris, T. & A ; Elmes, G. ( 1993 ) The application of GIS in urban and regional planning: a reappraisal of the North American experience. Applied Geography, pp. 9-27. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/014362289390077E.
Highways Agency ( 1994 ) Design Manual for Roads and Bridges. Volume, 11 ( August ) . Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //scholar.google.com/scholar? hl=en & A ; btnG=Search & A ; q=intitle: DESIGN+MANUAL+FOR+ROADS+AND+BRIDGES # 3.
Hix, D. , Swan, J. , Gabbard, J. , McGee, M. , Durbin, J. & A ; King, T. ( 1999 ) User-centered design and rating of a real-time battleground visual image practical environment. Proceedings IEEE Virtual Reality ( Cat. No. 99CB36316 ) ( Figure 1 ) , pp. 96-103. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //ieeexplore.ieee.org/lpdocs/epic03/wrapper.htm? arnumber=756939.
Isaacs, J. , Blackwood, D. , Falconer, R. & A ; Gilmour, D. ( 2007 ) The function of visual image in effectual sustainability appraisal. In M. Horner, C. Hardcastle, A. Price, & A ; J. Bebbington International Conference on Whole Life Urban Sustainability and its Assessment. Glasgow: Glasgow Caledonian university. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //download.sue-mot.org/Conference-2007/Papers/Isaacs.pdf.
Isaacs, J. , Falconer, R. , Gilmour, D. & A ; Blackwood, D. ( 2010 ) Enhancing urban sustainability utilizing 3D visual image. Proceedings Of The Institution Of Civil Engineers, p. IN PRESS.
Isaacs, J. , Falconer, R. , Gilmour, D. & A ; Blackwood, D. ( 2010 ) Sustainable urban developments: stakeholder battle through 3d visual image. In Continuing of the 11th IASTED International Conference Computer Graphics and Imaging. Innsbruck: IASTED, pp. 265-271.
Levkowitz, H. & A ; Herman, G. ( 1992 ) Color graduated tables for image informations. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications ( Cgim ) , p. 72-80. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.computer.org/portal/web/csdl/doi/10.1109/38.135886.
Levy, R. ( 1995 ) Visual image of urban options. Environment and Planning B, 22, p. 343-343. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //envplan.com/epb/fulltext/b22/b220343.pdf.
Lodha, S.K. & A ; Verma, A.K. ( 2000 ) Spatio-temporal visual image of urban offenses on a GIS grid. In ACM New York, NY, USA, pp. 174-179.
Lowe, R. ( 2003 ) Animation and acquisition: selective processing of information in dynamic artworks. Learning and Instruction, 13 ( 2 ) , pp. 157-176. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S095947520200018X.
Lowe, R. ( 2004 ) Question of a dynamic visual image during larning. Learning and Instruction, 14 ( 3 ) , pp. 257-274. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0959475204000313.
Paracchini, M.L. , Pacini, C. , Calvo, S. & A ; Vogt, J. ( 2008 ) Weighting and collection of indexs for sustainability impact appraisal in the SENSOR context. In Sustainability Impact Assessment of Land Use Changes. Berlin: Springer, pp. 349-372.
Parkin, S. , Sommer, F. & A ; Uren, S. ( 2003 ) Sustainable development: understanding the construct and practical challenge. Engineering Sustainability, 156 ( 1 ) , p. 19-26. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.atypon-link.com/telf/doi/abs/10.1680/ensu.126.96.36.199055.
Salter, J.D. , Campbell, C. , Journeay, M. & A ; Sheppard, S.R. ( 2009 ) The digital workshop: researching the usage of synergistic and immersive visual image tools in participatory planning. Journal of environmental direction, 90 ( 6 ) , pp. 2090-101. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18558460.
Shiffer, M. ( 1998 ) Multimedia GIS for be aftering support and public discourse. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 25 ( 2 ) , p. 89-94. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ingentaconnect.com/content/acsm/cagis/1998/00000025/00000002/art00004.
States, U. ( 2000 ) A Summary of Models for Measuring the Land-Use Patterns. Environmental Protection ( September ) .
Stevens, D. , Dragicevic, S. & A ; Rothley, K. ( 2007 ) iCity: A GIS-CA modeling tool for urban planning and determination devising. Environmental Modelling & A ; Software, 22 ( 6 ) , pp. 761-773. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1364815206000582.
Traynor, C. & A ; Williams, M.G. ( 1995 ) Why are geographic information systems hard to utilize? In CHI ’95: Conference comrade on Human factors in calculating systems. New York, NY, USA: ACM, pp. 288-289.
WCED ( 1987 ) Our common hereafter. Members of the Comission. Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //scholar.google.com/scholar? hl=en & A ; btnG=Search & A ; q=intitle: Our+Common+Future # 0.
White Young Green ( 2007 ) Traffic Signalling Modelling Report. Traffic ( March ) .